Auto-dial units are sold off the shelf with no monthly fee, and they look like the sensible saving. They work only if someone picks up. When a son is in a meeting and a daughter is driving the QEW, the unit moves down the list and may end with nobody at all. A monitored service has a trained person on the line within moments, who can stay talking to your parent while help is sent. For anyone who lives alone, the monitored route is usually worth the fee.
Auto-dial can make sense in one case: a couple at home together, where a spouse is nearly always within reach and wants a quick way to call a son or daughter. Even then, check that the unit can dial emergency services as a final step.
The contract deserves more attention than the hardware. Before signing, ask for the minimum term and the cancellation fee in writing, and whether the price is locked. Ask if you own the equipment or return it, and what a lost pendant costs. One question families forget: what happens if your parent moves into a retirement home in Ancaster or Stoney Creek? Many residences have their own call bells, so you'll want to cancel without a penalty.
Think about outages and upkeep too. The base station should have a battery backup that carries it through a storm, and it should warn the centre when the battery runs low. Press the button once a month to make a test call, and tell the centre first so they log it as a test. Replace the wearable's strap when it cracks, since a broken strap is how buttons end up in a kitchen drawer.